info@jonbergmann.com

Students Like Flipped Homework More!

I am about to complete a book about the relationship between flipped learning and homework.  While writing the book, I realized that I needed to hear from students about their perceptions and thoughts about flipped homework.  I reached out through my network of flipped teachers and asked them to have their students take a survey. Before looking at the survey results I want to emphasize that there is great debate about the value and purpose of homework.  Some educators feel that homework should never be assigned while others see it as a vital part of learning. I have read the research and have found studies on both sides of this issue.  The intention of this article is to focus on students perceptions in classes where teachers are sending home the flipped videos as homework prior to class.  The survey revealed some interesting data and insight into how flipped learning homework is perceived by the most important stakeholders in education, the students.  

2344 students from all over the world took the survey, the majority coming from the United States.

Students from all grade levels took the survey and most were in grades 6-12.

The most common subjects flipped were math and science, but there was a great representation of students in other subject areas.  The data below might also be deceptive as the percentages do not add up. This is because many of the students were in more than one flipped class at their schools.  

SubjectsFlipped

The first set of questions I asked revolved around the issue of time:  How long were their teacher’s flipped videos? How much time did it take students to complete a flipped video assignment, and did a flipped homework assignment take them more or less time than a non-flipped homework assignment?

minOfHW

 

I was encouraged by this response because I have been teaching teachers for years that to effectively flip a classroom, it is imperative that the videos be short.  Most teachers seem to be following best practices.  

TimeToWatch2
I was a bit surprised by this data. I generally think students should take between one and one-half to two times the length of the video interacting with the video content.  I see two options: either I am wrong and good comprehension can take much less time, or students could grow and learn how to more effectively interact with a flipped video.  

HomeworkTime

This data was very promising because the vast majority of students report that flipped homework is taking them less time.  But if students are spending less time on a flipped homework assignment, does that translate into lower performance and comprehension?  

I followed this question up with a question about comprehension of class content. Note, this data is all from the student perspective and has not been correlated with actual student achievement.  There are studies which have shown student achievement gains in flipped learning. The data below suggests higher student achievement but does not prove it. The question was asked on a 1-5 scale with a 1 indicating that flipped videos hurt their understanding of class content, and a 5 indicating that it greatly helped student understanding of class content.  

comprehension

The students were then asked if they had to choose between a flipped or a non-flipped course, which would they choose? As you can see below, most either prefer a flipped course, or have no preference.  

FlippedOrTraditional

I closed out the survey with two open-ended questions about advantages and disadvantages of a flipped video homework assignment.  With over 2000 responses, I have attempted to get a fair sampling of the students thoughts.  

Advantages

We can do assignments at all hours of the day.
You get to ask questions about homework while doing it in class
It helps us to do less work but understand better
When you watch the video first and then take notes and finally doing the homework, then that makes it a whole lot easier and less stressful.
I am more focused on the task and can learn at a better pace compared to when the teacher is teaching the entire classroom.
You can rewatch the videos if you don’t understand.
It is easier to understand and the homework doesn’t take as long.
We have a chance to do homework inside and outside of school.
You have a time to think and it is easy for you to pass your assignments and assessments.
My class has more time for discussion and my teacher can answer more questions that I have.
Students do harder things in class, and can have questions prepared for their teachers.
you can do it even if you are confused and then ask questions when you get to class . rather than not being able to do it at all.
In a traditional classroom the homework is a piece of paper that can easily be lost, but in a flipped class with electronic homework we can retrieve the homework as long as we have access to a computer
It is a lot easier and you do it on your own time and you learn at your own pace.

Disadvantages

As a note a large percentage of students said that there were no disadvantages, some being quite insistent about it.  

If you are confused you have to wait till tomorrow or it takes a while and sometimes they don’t help us so sometimes it’s really confusing.
We can’t ask questions while watching the video, we have to email our teacher or wait until class the next day.
Some of the disadvantages are that sometimes the video can be too long and I will have less time for other subjects.
I am a “hands on learner” so I don’t get it quite as much as I do at school.
It is difficult to stay focused on the subject.
I have to use my computer and my WIFI is awful
If a student doesn’t do a homework they will not know what they are going on, or if they are attempting to take notes and do not understand something they cannot get another explanation that they might understand (unless the teacher lets you ask questions about the notes the next day which our teacher does)
sometimes we need a teacher to teach us if we don’t get it.

As I look at the responses above and the remainder in the survey, there were definitely students who had some difficulty accessing the content.  This illustrates how important it is to ensure equitable access to a flipped video for all students. The other major theme is that students wanted help when they were first interacting with the content.  This is also touted as a strength in the increased interaction during class.  

The survey highlights several key findings:

  • Most students prefer the flipped classroom model
  • Most students spend less time on homework in a flipped class
  • Most students feel they understand class content greater in a flipped classroom
  • Students like the increased interaction they get with their teachers in a flipped class.
  • There is a need for greater training on how to ensure access for all students when a teacher first flips his/her class.
  • For those students who do not prefer a flipped classroom, more research needs to be done on why this is and what if anything needs to be changed or adapted to meet the needs of these students.  

3 Responses

  1. Lee Graves

    Jon,

    When is the book coming out? I would like to get it for some PD I do in our district that talks about homework. Your data is interesting that it matches much of the same results I have seen in surveying my students the last 4 years. Thanks for all of the work you do to promote flipped learning!

    1. Jon Bergmann

      Not sure. I have just spent the past 3 hours at my local Starbucks on some major edits. I have an awesome editor who is making the book much better. Once I get this done and her approval I will have a better idea. Thanks for your kind words.

  2. Pingback : Flipped Lessons — A Starter Guide – Math Magicians

Leave a Reply